“India’s AMCA: Cheapest 5th Gen Fighter Program, By Far

SOURCE: AFI

India’s Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft (AMCA), a 5.5th-generation stealth fighter jet program, has garnered attention not only for its technological ambition but also for its remarkably low development cost. With a Full-Scale Engineering Development (FSED) allocation of ?15,000 crore (approximately $1.8 billion) over a 10-year period, including the construction of five prototypes, the AMCA stands out as potentially the cheapest 5th-generation jet program in the world.

This article delves into the AMCA’s development budget and compares it to the project costs of other 5th-generation fighter programs globally, highlighting India’s cost-effective approach and its implications for the global aerospace industry.

The AMCA program, spearheaded by India’s Aeronautical Development Agency (ADA) under the Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO), aims to deliver a stealthy, multi-role fighter jet with advanced features like supercruise, sensor fusion, and low radar cross-section. Classified as a 5.5th-generation aircraft, the AMCA incorporates incremental 6th-generation technologies in its Mark 2 variant, positioning it as a bridge between current 5th-gen fighters and future air combat systems.

The ?15,000 crore ($1.8 billion) FSED allocation, approved by the Cabinet Committee on Security (CCS) in March 2024, covers the development of five prototypes over a 10-year period, with a target for the first flight by 2028 and induction by 2034. This budget includes design, testing, integration of systems, and initial production activities. At roughly $360 million per prototype, the AMCA’s development cost is notably lean compared to other 5th-generation programs, raising questions about how India manages to achieve such efficiency while still aiming for cutting-edge technology.

To understand the AMCA’s cost-effectiveness, let’s examine the development budgets of other 5th-generation fighter programs globally. While exact figures vary due to differing accounting methods, inflation, and program scope, publicly available estimates provide a rough benchmark for comparison.

1. Lockheed Martin F-35 Lightning II (United States)

The F-35 program, led by Lockheed Martin, is the most extensive and expensive 5th-generation fighter program to date. Initiated in the 1990s, the F-35’s development costs have ballooned over the years due to its complexity, multinational collaboration, and the integration of three variants (F-35A, B, and C) for different roles.

• Estimated Development Cost: Approximately $55 billion (adjusted for inflation) over the course of its System Development and Demonstration (SDD) phase, which ran from 2001 to 2018.
• Prototypes: The program included several prototypes and test aircraft, with the X-35 demonstrators alone costing hundreds of millions.
• Per-Unit Cost: Around $80–110 million per jet in recent production lots, excluding R&D.
• Analysis: The F-35’s massive budget reflects its role as a multi-role, multi-service platform for the U.S. and its allies, with significant investments in stealth, avionics, and software. The AMCA’s $1.8 billion FSED budget is a fraction of this, underscoring India’s focus on cost containment.

2. Lockheed Martin F-22 Raptor (United States)

The F-22 Raptor, the first operational 5th-generation fighter, was developed by Lockheed Martin for the U.S. Air Force and entered service in 2005. Designed for air superiority, it set the standard for stealth and agility but came with a hefty price tag.

• Estimated Development Cost: Around $28 billion for the Engineering, Manufacturing, and Development (EMD) phase, spanning the 1990s to early 2000s.
• Prototypes: Two YF-22 prototypes were built for competitive fly-offs against the YF-23, costing approximately $700 million combined.
• Per-Unit Cost: Approximately $150 million per aircraft (adjusted for inflation), excluding R&D.
• Analysis: The F-22’s development cost dwarfs the AMCA’s budget by a factor of 15. While the F-22 pioneered many 5th-gen technologies, its high cost led to production being capped at 187 units, highlighting the economic challenges of such programs.

3. Sukhoi Su-57 Felon (Russia)

Russia’s Su-57, developed by Sukhoi, is a 5th-generation multi-role fighter designed to compete with Western jets like the F-22 and F-35. Despite delays and technical challenges, the Su-57 entered limited service with the Russian Air Force in 2020.

• Estimated Development Cost: Estimates vary widely, but reports suggest $10–15 billion for the PAK FA (Future Aviation Complex for Frontline Aviation) program, including prototypes and testing.
• Prototypes: Around 10 T-50 prototypes were built for testing, with costs per prototype estimated at $100–150 million.
• Per-Unit Cost: Approximately $40–50 million per aircraft, though this figure is speculative due to limited transparency.
• Analysis: The Su-57’s development cost, while lower than U.S. programs, still significantly exceeds the AMCA’s budget. Russia’s lower labor and production costs contribute to this, but the program has faced criticism for not fully meeting 5th-gen standards in stealth and avionics.

4. Chengdu J-20 Mighty Dragon (China)

China’s J-20, developed by Chengdu Aerospace Corporation, is a 5th-generation stealth fighter that entered service with the People’s Liberation Army Air Force (PLAAF) in 2017. The program is shrouded in secrecy, making cost estimates less precise.

• Estimated Development Cost: Analysts estimate $5–10 billion for R&D, though some sources suggest higher figures due to China’s rapid scaling of production.
• Prototypes: Several prototypes (around 6–8) were built, with costs per prototype likely in the $50–100 million range.
• Per-Unit Cost: Estimated at $50–70 million per jet, though this varies with production scale.
• Analysis: The J-20’s development cost, while lower than Western programs, still exceeds the AMCA’s budget by a factor of 3–5. China’s state-driven approach and economies of scale likely helped manage costs, but the program remains far more expensive than India’s effort.

5. KAI KF-21 Boramae (South Korea)

South Korea’s KF-21 Boramae, developed by Korea Aerospace Industries (KAI) with Indonesian collaboration, is a 4.5th to 5th-generation fighter designed to bridge current and future technologies. It conducted its first flight in 2022.

• Estimated Development Cost: Around $8.5 billion for the entire program, including R&D and initial production.
• Prototypes: Six prototypes were built, with costs estimated at $100–150 million per prototype.
• Per-Unit Cost: Approximately $50–60 million per jet in initial batches.
• Analysis: The KF-21’s cost is closer to the AMCA’s than other 5th-gen programs, but it still exceeds India’s budget by a factor of 4–5. The KF-21 benefits from South Korea’s advanced industrial base and U.S. technical support, which may inflate costs compared to India’s more frugal approach.

6. TAI TF Kaan (Turkey)

Turkey’s TF Kaan, developed by Turkish Aerospace Industries (TAI), is a 5th-generation fighter aimed at replacing aging F-16s in the Turkish Air Force. The program is still in its early stages, with its maiden flight in 2024.

• Estimated Development Cost: Around $10–12 billion projected for R&D and initial production, though costs may rise as the program matures.
• Prototypes: At least two prototypes have been built, with costs per prototype likely in the $150–200 million range.
• Per-Unit Cost: Estimated at $80–100 million per jet once production scales up.
• Analysis: The TF Kaan’s development cost is significantly higher than the AMCA’s, reflecting Turkey’s reliance on foreign partnerships (e.g., Rolls-Royce for engines) and the challenges of building a 5th-gen platform from scratch.

NOTE: AFI is a proud outsourced content creator partner of IDRW.ORG. All content created by AFI is the sole property of AFI and is protected by copyright. AFI takes copyright infringement seriously and will pursue all legal options available to protect its content.