SOURCE: AFI
India’s quest to modernize its air force has led to discussions about acquiring advanced fighter jets, with the Lockheed Martin F-35 Lightning II and the Dassault Rafale F4 emerging as potential contenders. This article compares the acquisition costs for 110 units of each aircraft and estimates their 40-year life cycle costs (LCC) if procured by the Indian Air Force (IAF). Life cycle costs include acquisition, operating, maintenance, and support expenses over the aircraft’s operational lifespan, providing a comprehensive view of the long-term financial commitment.
The F-35, a fifth-generation stealth fighter, is available in three variants: F-35A (conventional takeoff and landing), F-35B (short takeoff and vertical landing), and F-35C (carrier-based). For the IAF, the F-35A is the most likely option due to its compatibility with land-based operations and lower cost compared to the B and C variants.
As of 2023, the F-35A’s unit cost has decreased significantly due to economies of scale and production efficiencies. The flyaway cost is approximately $82.5 million per unit, according to Lockheed Martin and US government data. However, export prices typically include additional costs such as training, spares, and support equipment, pushing the effective unit cost to around $100-110 million.
Assuming an export price of $110 million per unit, the total acquisition cost for 110 F-35As would be approximately $12.1 billion. This figure includes initial spares, training, and basic support infrastructure but excludes weapons packages, which would add further costs depending on India’s requirements.
The Rafale F4, an advanced 4.5-generation multi-role fighter, is currently in service with the IAF, with 36 units already procured under a 2016 deal. The F4 variant, an upgrade over the F3R standard, features enhanced radar, improved sensors, and network-centric warfare capabilities.
The cost of the Rafale has varied depending on the contract and customization. For India’s initial deal, the 36 Rafales cost €7.87 billion (approximately $8.7 billion at 2016 exchange rates), equating to about $242 million per unit, including India-specific enhancements, weapons, spares, and infrastructure. However, subsequent deals for other nations, such as Egypt and Indonesia, suggest a lower flyaway cost of $115-130 million per unit for the base aircraft, with additional costs for customization and support. For this analysis, we assume a unit cost of $130 million for the F4 variant, reflecting a standardized export price without extensive India-specific modifications.
At $130 million per unit, the total acquisition cost for 110 Rafale F4s would be approximately $14.3 billion. This estimate includes basic spares and training but excludes weapons and additional infrastructure, which could increase the total cost depending on the IAF’s specific requirements.
Life Cycle Cost (LCC) Estimation Over 40 Years
Life cycle costs encompass acquisition, operating, maintenance, and support expenses over the aircraft’s operational lifespan. For this analysis, we assume a 40-year service life, consistent with modern fighter jets, and consider key cost drivers such as fuel, maintenance, personnel, upgrades, and spares.
The F-35 is known for its high operating and maintenance costs, primarily due to its stealth features, advanced electronics, and complex logistics requirements. The US Government Accountability Office (GAO) and other sources provide data that can be adapted for an India-specific estimate.
The F-35A’s operating cost is approximately $33,000 per flight hour (as of 2023), though Lockheed Martin aims to reduce this to $25,000 by 2025. For this analysis, we use a conservative average of $30,000 per flight hour over 40 years.
Assuming each F-35 flies 250 hours per year (a standard estimate for fighter jets), the annual operating cost per aircraft is $7.5 million.
Per aircraft: $7.5 million/year × 40 years = $300 million
For 110 aircraft: $300 million × 110 = $33 billion
Maintenance costs for the F-35 are significant, driven by its stealth coatings, advanced sensors, and software updates. Estimates suggest maintenance accounts for 60-70% of operating costs. Assuming 65% of the operating cost ($19,500 per flight hour), the total maintenance cost over 40 years is approximately $21.45 billion for 110 units.
Over 40 years, periodic upgrades (e.g., software, avionics, and stealth enhancements) and spares could add 20-30% to the LCC. Assuming 25% of the combined operating and maintenance costs ($13.61 billion), the total rises significantly.
- Total LCC for 110 F-35As:
- Acquisition: $12.1 billion
- Operating: $33 billion
- Maintenance: $21.45 billion
- Upgrades and Spares: $13.61 billion
- Total: $80.16 billion
The Rafale, while not a stealth aircraft, is renowned for its reliability, versatility, and lower operating costs compared to fifth-generation fighters. Data from the French Air Force and India’s existing Rafale fleet provide a basis for estimation.
The Rafale’s operating cost is approximately $16,500 per flight hour, significantly lower than the F-35 due to its simpler maintenance requirements and lack of stealth-specific upkeep. Assuming 250 hours per year per aircraft, the annual operating cost per Rafale is $4.125 million.
Per aircraft: $4.125 million/year × 40 years = $165 million
For 110 aircraft: $165 million × 110 = $18.15 billion
Maintenance costs for the Rafale are estimated at 50-60% of operating costs due to its robust design and lower complexity. Assuming 55% ($9,075 per flight hour), the total maintenance cost over 40 years is approximately $9.98 billion for 110 units.
Upgrades and spares for the Rafale, including radar enhancements and weapon integration, are estimated at 20-25% of combined operating and maintenance costs. Assuming 22.5% ($6.28 billion), the total increases accordingly.
- Total LCC for 110 Rafale F4s:
- Acquisition: $14.3 billion
- Operating: $18.15 billion
- Maintenance: $9.98 billion
- Upgrades and Spares: $6.28 billion
- Total: $48.71 billion
The Rafale F4 is $2.2 billion more expensive upfront, reflecting its higher unit cost and customization potential. However, the F-35’s lower flyaway cost is offset by its higher export price and additional support requirements. The F-35’s 40-year LCC is $31.45 billion higher than the Rafale F4, a 64.6% increase. This substantial gap is driven by the F-35’s significantly higher operating and maintenance costs, attributed to its stealth features, complex electronics, and logistics.
For 110 units, the F-35A’s acquisition cost of $12.1 billion is lower than the Rafale F4’s $14.3 billion, but its 40-year life cycle cost of $80.16 billion far exceeds the Rafale F4’s $48.71 billion. The Rafale F4 emerges as the more cost-effective option over the long term, offering significant savings that could be redirected to indigenous programs or other defense needs. However, the F-35’s fifth-generation capabilities provide a strategic edge that the Rafale cannot match, making it a compelling choice if India prioritizes technological superiority over cost. Ultimately, the IAF’s decision will hinge on balancing strategic requirements, budgetary constraints, and long-term self-reliance goals, with the Rafale F4 likely favored for its cost-effectiveness and operational synergy with India’s existing fleet.
NOTE: AFI is a proud outsourced content creator partner of IDRW.ORG. All content created by AFI is the sole property of AFI and is protected by copyright. AFI takes copyright infringement seriously and will pursue all legal options available to protect its content.