SOURCE: AFI
In a recent statement, Eric Trappier, CEO of Dassault Aviation, the manufacturer of the Rafale fighter jet, has cast doubt on Pakistan’s claims regarding the alleged destruction of three Rafale aircraft during a conflict with India. Trappier’s remarks come amid heightened tensions and conflicting narratives between the two nations, with Pakistan asserting significant losses on the Indian side.
Trappier emphasized that the Indian government has not provided detailed communication regarding the incident, leaving the exact events unclear. “The Indians did not communicate, so we do not know exactly what happened,” he stated. However, he directly challenged Pakistan’s claims, saying, “What we already know is that the words of the Pakistanis [three destroyed Rafale, ed] are inaccurate.”
Drawing a historical parallel, Trappier contextualized the concept of military losses in combat operations. “When you operate combat aircraft, you complete a mission. The success of the mission is not having zero loss, it is having achieved its objectives,” he explained. He referenced the Second World War, noting that the Allies were not deemed to have lost the war despite suffering significant casualties. “We will see if there were losses or not, and if the war goals were achieved. When the truth comes out, some may have surprises,” he added, hinting at the possibility of forthcoming clarity that could challenge existing narratives.
Pakistani defense analysts and media outlets had claimed that up to three Indian Rafale fighter jets were shot down during the conflict, with one allegedly piloted by Squadron Leader Shivangi Singh. However, no visual evidence, wreckage, or official confirmation from Indian authorities has surfaced to support these claims. The Indian Air Force has remained tight-lipped on the matter, adhering to a policy of operational silence.
This is not the first time that military engagements between India and Pakistan have been clouded by competing narratives and psychological operations. In 2019, following the Balakot air strikes, both nations offered conflicting accounts of air combat outcomes, with Pakistan claiming to have downed Indian jets and India asserting similar claims in return.
The Rafale, a 4.5-generation omnirole fighter, has become a cornerstone of India’s frontline airpower since its induction. Manufactured by France’s Dassault Aviation, the aircraft is known for its electronic warfare capabilities, advanced radar systems, and the ability to deliver long-range precision-guided munitions like the SCALP cruise missile.
While speculation around losses continues in open-source circles, Trappier’s comments serve as a rare insider perspective from the manufacturer, affirming confidence in the platform and its operational performance under Indian command. Whether India will eventually disclose the full extent of its operational outcomes remains to be seen, but as Trappier noted, the ultimate measure of success lies in achieving strategic objectives, not merely avoiding losses.
NOTE: AFI is a proud outsourced content creator partner of IDRW.ORG. All content created by AFI is the sole property of AFI and is protected by copyright. AFI takes copyright infringement seriously and will pursue all legal options available to protect its content.